Medical Mutual OTC 2027: Allowance by Plan, Login, Catalog and Stores
Reviewed November 14, 2026. Medical Mutual OTC benefits for 2027 come only with select MedMutual Advantage plans. In the 2027 plans we checked, the allowance is $20 or $25 each quarter, down from 2026, and some plans have no OTC benefit at all. Medical Mutual says the allowance loads on a Benefits Mastercard Prepaid Card run by NationsBenefits, which you can use at stores like Kroger, Walgreens, Walmart and Giant Eagle or online.
- 2027 amounts we verified: $20 a quarter on Plus HMO (H6723-003-003); $25 a quarter on Select PPO (H4497-001-003) and Premium PPO (H4497-003-003).
- No OTC listed for 2027: Classic HMO-POS (H6723-001-003), Choice HMO (H6723-002-003) and Preferred PPO (H4497-002-003).
- Card: Benefits Mastercard Prepaid Card, administered by NationsBenefits (per Medical Mutual’s OTC page).
- Reloads: January 1, April 1, July 1 and October 1. Unused money does not carry over.
- Login: My Health Plan at MedMutual.com/Member, then the Benefits Pro Portal under Claims & Balances.
- Help: Medical Mutual Customer Care, 1-800-982-3117 (TTY 711).

Medical Mutual OTC allowance by plan: 2026 vs 2027
Benefits vary by plan and county. The table below covers the 2027 MedMutual Advantage plans whose documents we could open on Medical Mutual’s site. Each one lists its service area on the cover of its Annual Notice of Change (ANOC). The HMO plans serve 19 southwest and central Ohio counties, including Franklin, Hamilton and Montgomery. The PPO plans add Fulton, Lucas, Ottawa, Sandusky and Wood counties.
| 2027 plan (contract-plan ID) | 2026 OTC allowance | 2027 OTC allowance | 2027 monthly premium |
|---|---|---|---|
| MedMutual Advantage Plus HMO (H6723-003-003) | $60 each quarter | $20 each quarter ($80 a year) | $103 |
| MedMutual Advantage Select PPO (H4497-001-003) | $50 each quarter | $25 each quarter ($100 a year) | $58 |
| MedMutual Advantage Premium PPO (H4497-003-003) | $35 each quarter | $25 each quarter ($100 a year) | $168 |
| MedMutual Advantage Classic HMO-POS (H6723-001-003) | See your 2027 ANOC | None listed in the 2027 Summary of Benefits | See Summary of Benefits |
| MedMutual Advantage Choice HMO (H6723-002-003) | No change listed in ANOC | None listed on the 2027 plan page | See Summary of Benefits |
| MedMutual Advantage Preferred PPO (H4497-002-003) | No OTC row in ANOC | None listed on the 2027 plan page | See Summary of Benefits |
The 2027 Summary of Benefits for Select PPO, Plus HMO and Premium PPO each says unused amounts “do NOT carry over from quarter to quarter or to the next calendar year.” Medical Mutual also offers plans in other Ohio counties. If your plan isn’t in the table, open its documents by county on Medical Mutual’s 2027 plan information page. Your Evidence of Coverage (EOC) is the final word on your benefit.
What about Signature HMO-POS and Access PPO?
Medical Mutual’s 2026 welcome pages list $30 each quarter for MedMutual Advantage Signature HMO-POS and $40 each quarter for MedMutual Advantage Access PPO. We did not find 2027 documents for those plan names. If you’re in one of them, your 2027 ANOC explains what changes on January 1, 2027.
The Medical Mutual OTC card
Medical Mutual’s OTC benefits page, updated October 1, 2026, names the card as the Benefits Mastercard Prepaid Card, issued by The Bancorp Bank N.A. NationsBenefits is Medical Mutual’s OTC partner. The 2027 plan documents call it “your benefit card” and don’t repeat the card’s brand name. For general background, see how OTC benefit cards work.
| Feature | What Medical Mutual says |
|---|---|
| Card | Benefits Mastercard Prepaid Card, issued by The Bancorp Bank N.A.; OTC partner NationsBenefits |
| How often it loads | Each quarter: January 1, April 1, July 1 and October 1 |
| Rollover | Unused balances do not roll over |
| In stores | Kroger, Discount Drug Mart, Walgreens, Walmart and Giant Eagle; choose CREDIT, no PIN needed |
| Online | Benefits Pro Portal or app with free shipping; Walmart.com accepts the card; Amazon.com does not |
| Order deadline | Place online and mail orders at least 10 days before the quarter ends |
How to log in and order Medical Mutual OTC items
- Sign in. Go to MedMutual.com/Member and log in to My Health Plan.
- Open the portal. Choose Claims & Balances, then the Benefits Pro Portal. You can also use the Benefits Pro app for iPhone or Android.
- Shop the catalog. Add eligible items up to your quarterly balance. Online orders ship free.
- Check out before the deadline. Order at least 10 days before the quarter ends.
A few ordering rules from Medical Mutual: orders above your balance aren’t reimbursed, so pay the difference or remove items. You can’t buy eligible and ineligible items in the same transaction. Products can’t be returned, but you can cancel an order before it ships. Medical Mutual Customer Care is 1-800-982-3117 (TTY 711), Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern, except major holidays. If you have trouble signing in, see our OTC benefits login guide by plan.
How to check your Medical Mutual OTC balance
Log in to My Health Plan. Medical Mutual says your balance shows under “My NationsBenefits” on the dashboard. You can also see it in the Benefits Pro app, or call Customer Care at the number above or on the back of your card. Because the balance resets every quarter, check it a few weeks before March 31, June 30, September 30 and December 31. More tips: how to check your OTC card balance.
Medical Mutual OTC catalog and eligible items
The catalog link at MedMutual.com/OTC still opens the 2026 eligible product catalog. We did not find a 2027 catalog as of November 14, 2026. Medical Mutual lists these eligible categories:
- Cold and flu, pain relief and first aid
- Dental care, eye and ear care, and skin care
- Diabetes care and diagnostics
- Digestive care and foot care
- Vitamins and dietary supplements
- Incontinence supplies and home health care
- Supports and braces, and therapy and exercise
- Smoking cessation
The exact product list can change each year, so check the catalog that applies to your plan year. For a general overview, see what you can buy with an OTC card.
Where can I use my Medical Mutual OTC card?
In stores, Medical Mutual names Kroger, Discount Drug Mart, Walgreens, Walmart and Giant Eagle as part of the NationsBenefits OTC network. Use the store locator in the Benefits Pro Portal to confirm a location before you go. At the register, swipe the card and choose CREDIT. Medical Mutual says choosing debit causes a decline. Online, the card works at Walmart.com but not Amazon.com. See stores that accept OTC cards, using OTC benefits at Walmart and does Amazon accept OTC cards.
Choosing a MedMutual Advantage plan for 2027
Several 2027 plans cut the OTC allowance, and some have none. If OTC matters to you, compare plans during Medicare Open Enrollment, October 15 to December 7, 2026. A $25 quarterly allowance is $100 a year, so weigh it against premiums, doctors, drug coverage and dental benefits. To compare insurers, see Medicare Advantage plans with OTC benefits. You can also compare plans on the Medicare Plan Finder.
Frequently asked questions
How much is the Medical Mutual OTC allowance in 2027?
It depends on your plan. In the 2027 plans we checked, Plus HMO (H6723-003-003) gives $20 a quarter, and Select PPO (H4497-001-003) and Premium PPO (H4497-003-003) give $25 a quarter. Check your 2027 Summary of Benefits.
Do all MedMutual Advantage plans have OTC benefits?
No. Medical Mutual says OTC is on “select” plans. The 2027 Classic HMO-POS, Choice HMO and Preferred PPO plans we checked don’t list one.
How do I log in to my Medical Mutual OTC account?
Sign in at MedMutual.com/Member, go to Claims & Balances and open the Benefits Pro Portal, or use the Benefits Pro app.
Does my Medical Mutual OTC balance roll over?
No. Unused money doesn’t carry over to the next quarter or the next calendar year.
Can I use my Medical Mutual OTC card on Amazon?
No. Medical Mutual says the card works on Walmart.com but not Amazon.com.
This article is general information, not plan-specific advice. Benefits vary by plan and county; check your plan’s Summary of Benefits and Evidence of Coverage. Medicare365 is not affiliated with Medical Mutual, NationsBenefits or the U.S. government.
Sources
- Medical Mutual: OTC Benefits
- 2027 Summary of Benefits: Plus HMO (H6723-003-003) and 2027 ANOC
- 2027 Summary of Benefits: Select PPO (H4497-001-003) and 2027 ANOC
- 2027 Summary of Benefits: Premium PPO (H4497-003-003) and 2027 ANOC
- 2027 Summary of Benefits: Classic HMO-POS (H6723-001-003)
- Medical Mutual 2027 plan pages: Plus HMO, Select PPO, Premium PPO, Classic HMO-POS, Choice HMO, Preferred PPO
- Medical Mutual 2026 welcome pages: Signature HMO-POS and Access PPO
- Medical Mutual: 2027 plan documents by county
- Medicare.gov: Medicare Plan Finder