YouTube 1-844-552-7426
Home  /  OTC & Flex Cards  /  Healthfirst OTC Card 2027: OTC Plus Amounts, Balance and Where to Use It

Healthfirst OTC Card 2027: OTC Plus Amounts, Balance and Where to Use It

Updated November 14, 2026

Reviewed November 14, 2026. The Healthfirst OTC card, officially called the OTC Plus card, is a prepaid Visa-logo benefits card that comes with five Healthfirst Medicare Advantage plans in New York. For 2027, Healthfirst lists monthly amounts from $10 (65 Plus Plan) to $256 (CompleteCare), and unused money does not roll over. All members can use it for over-the-counter health items; in Healthfirst’s D-SNP plans, members with a qualifying chronic condition can also use it for healthy food, utilities and more.

Illustration of a Healthfirst Medicare Advantage OTC Plus benefits card

Healthfirst OTC card amounts: 2026 vs 2027

Healthfirst publishes OTC Plus amounts for both years on its member OTC page. All five plans below are offered under Healthfirst’s Medicare contract H3359, according to Healthfirst’s 2027 Star Ratings document for these plans. Your exact plan number (the three digits after H3359) depends on your plan and county, so confirm it on your member ID card or in Medicare Plan Finder.

Healthfirst plan (contract H3359)2026 monthly amount2027 monthly amountChange
CompleteCare (HMO D-SNP)$252$256+$4
Life Improvement Plan (HMO D-SNP)$175$180+$5
Connection Plan (HMO D-SNP)$55$45-$10
Increased Benefits Plan (HMO)$35$35No change
65 Plus Plan (HMO)$25$10-$15
Source: Healthfirst Over-the-Counter (OTC) Benefits page, 2026 and 2027 plan years, checked November 14, 2026.

Two plans drop in 2027: the 65 Plus Plan falls from $25 to $10 a month, and the Connection Plan falls from $55 to $45. Benefits vary by plan and county and can change each year. Your plan’s 2027 Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) lists what changed, and the 2027 Evidence of Coverage (EOC) has the full rules. Both are on the Healthfirst plan documents page. If the OTC amount matters to you, compare plans during Medicare Open Enrollment, October 15 to December 7, 2026. For other carriers, see our list of New York plans that give an OTC card.

What you can buy with the Healthfirst OTC Plus card in 2027

Every plan’s card covers over-the-counter non-prescription drugs and health items, such as pain relievers, vitamins and eye drops, plus exercise equipment and activity trackers. Other uses depend on your plan.

2027 planAll membersMembers with a qualifying chronic condition
CompleteCare (HMO D-SNP)OTC health items, exercise equipment, activity trackersHealthy foods, home utilities, cell phone bills, personal care items, household cleaning supplies
Life Improvement Plan (HMO D-SNP)OTC health items, exercise equipment, activity trackers, PERSHealthy foods, home utilities, personal care items, household cleaning supplies, humidifiers
Connection Plan (HMO D-SNP)OTC health items, exercise equipment, activity trackers, PERSHealthy foods, home utilities, personal care items, household cleaning supplies, humidifiers
Increased Benefits Plan (HMO)OTC health items, exercise equipment, activity trackers, PERSNot offered
65 Plus Plan (HMO)OTC health items, exercise equipment, activity trackersNot offered
Source: Healthfirst Over-the-Counter (OTC) Benefits page, 2027 plan year. PERS means personal emergency response system.

Healthfirst says CompleteCare members may also qualify for a PERS device and a humidifier by calling Member Services. The 65 Plus Plan included PERS in 2026 but does not list it for 2027. Home utilities include gas, oil, electric, water and internet service. For a general list of what OTC cards usually cover, see what you can get with an OTC card.

The chronic condition rule for food and utilities

Food, utilities and the other extra uses are special supplemental benefits for the chronically ill (SSBCI). Starting in 2027, you need a qualifying chronic condition to use them. Healthfirst gives examples such as cardiovascular disorders, diabetes, disabling mental health conditions, lung disorders and obesity. Having the condition alone does not guarantee eligibility.

What the card can’t be used for

Healthfirst also notes that eligible items can change month to month and some brands may not be eligible at every store. Your plan’s 2027 OTC Plus Eligible Item Guide, in your online account or the app, has the full list.

Where to use your Healthfirst OTC card in 2027

Bring the OTC Plus card itself (or the digital card in the Healthfirst NY app). Your Healthfirst member ID card and Medicare card won’t work at the register. If the card reader asks for a PIN, Healthfirst says to cancel and run the purchase as “credit.” If you have trouble paying with the card, you may be able to get reimbursed; contact Member Services. Stores can change, so check the store locator in the app or on MyHFNY.org before you shop. To compare with other plans, see what stores accept OTC cards.

How to activate your Healthfirst OTC Plus card

You must activate the card before your first purchase. Have your OTC Plus card number (on the front of the card) and your Healthfirst Medicare member ID number ready. Then use one of these options:

  1. Call 1-833-684-8472, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
  2. Sign in at MyHFNY.org.
  3. Use the Healthfirst NY mobile app.

How to check your Healthfirst OTC card balance and log in

MethodHow
TextText BAL to HF4YOU (434968)
Online loginSign in to your member account at MyHFNY.org
AppHealthfirst NY mobile app (also holds your digital OTC Plus card)
Phone helpOTC Plus line, 1-833-684-8472, 24/7
Source: Healthfirst Over-the-Counter (OTC) Benefits page, 2027 plan year.

Your allowance loads each month. Healthfirst says, “Any unused balances will automatically expire at the end of each month, or upon disenrollment or transfer to another Healthfirst plan.” You also can’t borrow from next month’s amount. Plan your purchases so you don’t lose money at month’s end. For tips that apply to any plan, see how to check your OTC card balance.

Healthfirst contact numbers

NeedPhone
OTC Plus card activation and help1-833-684-8472 (24/7)
Healthfirst Member Services (also lost or stolen card)1-888-260-1010
TTY (English)1-888-542-3821
TTY (Spanish)1-888-867-4132
Lifestation (PERS orders)1-888-360-8108
Mom’s Meals1-877-347-3438
Source: Healthfirst Over-the-Counter (OTC) Benefits page, checked November 14, 2026.

Healthfirst lists Member Services hours as 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., seven days a week from October through March, and Monday to Friday from April through September.

Healthfirst D-SNP plans and New York Medicaid

The three plans with the largest OTC amounts (CompleteCare, Life Improvement Plan and Connection Plan) are dual special needs plans (D-SNPs) for people who have both Medicare and New York Medicaid. CompleteCare has stricter rules. Healthfirst says you need Medicare Part A and Part B, full Medicaid coverage and a nursing home level of care at enrollment, plus a need for community-based long-term care services for more than 120 days. It is offered in New York City and Nassau, Orange, Rockland, Sullivan and Westchester counties.

Healthfirst also notes that New York Medicaid recertification and work requirement changes start January 1, 2027, but they do not apply to dual members age 65 and older. Members under 65 can get free help from SPS Community Solutions at 1-844-559-4219. To learn more, read our guide to Medicaid in New York, or see whether you qualify for Medicare Savings Programs or Extra Help.

Comparing Healthfirst with other plans

An OTC card shouldn’t be the only reason you pick a plan. Check that your doctors, hospitals and prescriptions are covered first, and review drug costs in each plan’s 2027 ANOC. Read how OTC benefits cards work, our list of Medicare Advantage plans with OTC allowances and the pros and cons of Medicare Advantage. Another New York option is covered in our EmblemHealth OTC card guide, and more plans are in Medicare Advantage plans in New York.

Frequently asked questions

How much is the Healthfirst OTC card for 2027?

Healthfirst lists 2027 monthly amounts of $256 (CompleteCare), $180 (Life Improvement Plan), $45 (Connection Plan), $35 (Increased Benefits Plan) and $10 (65 Plus Plan).

How do I check my Healthfirst OTC card balance?

Text BAL to HF4YOU (434968), sign in at MyHFNY.org or open the Healthfirst NY app. For card help, call 1-833-684-8472.

Does the Healthfirst OTC balance roll over?

No. Unused balances expire at the end of each month, and also if you disenroll or move to another Healthfirst plan.

Can I use the Healthfirst OTC card for groceries in 2027?

Only in the D-SNP plans (CompleteCare, Life Improvement Plan and Connection Plan), and only if you have a qualifying chronic condition. The Increased Benefits Plan and 65 Plus Plan cards don’t cover food.

Can I use my Healthfirst OTC card on Amazon?

Yes, for 2027. Healthfirst lists Amazon.com, Walmart.com and Instacart.com as online options.

Why was my Healthfirst OTC card declined?

Common reasons are a card that isn’t activated, an item that isn’t eligible for your plan, or a used-up monthly balance. If asked for a PIN, cancel and run the sale as “credit.” If problems continue, call Member Services at 1-888-260-1010.

This article is general information. Medicare365 is not affiliated with or endorsed by Healthfirst or any U.S. government agency. Benefits vary by plan and county and can change; confirm details in your plan’s Evidence of Coverage or with Healthfirst.

Sources

Medicare365